
Customers ask us this several times a day. The answer is simple in my mind, even if it takes a while to explain: no single manufacturer has ever been best for every need. That has been true my whole career in the window film industry, and since Made In The Shade opened in 1980.
Why we don’t sell just one brand
I was a 3M Advanced Certified Trainer from 1998 to 2008, and I watched 3M try again and again to build a program with good films and good marketing. Each time, it led to more warranty claims, or to shortfalls in roll sizes or appearance. In our last two years as a dealer we turned in almost $40,000 in warranty claims. The most popular or oldest brand is not always the best. In 2008 we parted ways with 3M.
Dealers leave manufacturers for many reasons: film failures, slow warranty service, slow payment of co-op and warranty claims, unattractive films, films that break glass, poor service, and unfair business practices. When a dealer leaves for reasons like these, the customer benefits.
Before 1998, we chose whichever films best fit each customer. Then 3M pressured us to become more and more exclusive, until by 2001 about 90% of what we sold was 3M. The rest were films 3M didn’t make, or sizes it couldn’t supply.
A short history of window film
The first window films were largely happy accidents: dyed plastic with high failure rates. Silver films, made by vapor-depositing aluminum onto plastic, came early, followed by copper and many other metals. Over the decades, manufacturers have used many coloring systems and metal and alloy combinations.
Who invented window film? It’s debated. Madico says it was founded before 3M, under the name Hysil. 3M holds an early patent on dyed polyester film, but that doesn’t mean it was first. Honestly, it doesn’t matter. Today’s films are nothing like the originals. What matters is who makes good film now, and who still makes it themselves. 3M is probably the biggest outsourcer in the industry, with other companies making whole films or components for it.
The main types of sun control film
- Reflective: copper and shiny aluminum.
- Reflective neutral: gray to gray-black, using duller metals like stainless steel, nichrome and titanium.
- Dual reflective: more reflective outside than inside, for better night vision.
- Non-reflective: mostly dye, with no metal or ceramic. These fade or change color within 1 to 5 years.
- Spectrally selective: let in much more visible light while blocking a large share of infrared heat.
Here are the brands we prefer in each category for solar control, safety and security and decorative film, and why.
Dual reflective (night vision) films
Our favorites are Madico Sunscape Select SL 18, the SunTek dual reflective series, and SolarGard True View. Customers have recently favored SunTek and Sunscape Select at 15% to 18% visible light, because they have the lowest interior (13%) and exterior (37%) reflectivity and lower emissivity (0.63) than others. They look less mirrored from outside, you can see out at night with the lights on, and they reduce heat transfer day and night, all year.
True View and Sunscape give the most natural view out, though not everyone likes True View’s amber exterior. Most dual reflectives look black, gray-black or silver; generally, the darker the film, the more reflective outside.
Other dual reflectives, such as Vista (Eastman, which also makes LLumar) and Panorama (Saint-Gobain, which also makes SolarGard), are in our opinion too reflective inside and out. They are sold as night vision films, but at night you mostly see your own reflection. Hanita makes very clear films with solid performance, and excellent exterior dual reflectives with the best warranty.
Reflective and metalized films
Silver and bronze: every manufacturer makes them. They are among the highest heat reducers because they are so reflective, but they share one drawback: at night with the lights on, the inside becomes a mirror. We have used Madico bronze for decades with zero warranty issues, and we think it looks best. Silver from any major manufacturer is fine.
Neutral metalized: we prefer Sunscape Select DG 35, 45 and 55. 3M’s Neutral 20, 35, 50 and 70 series is the only 3M film I recommend: solid and attractive.
Non-reflective metalized: usually a metal layer sandwiched between two dye layers. We rarely install these, because of the heavy dye content that fades or changes color, and the short 1- to 5-year warranties. We have used LLumar and SolarGard most often.
Spectrally selective films
Here we have to start with the granddaddy: V-Kool. It comes from Southwall Technologies, which also makes Huper Optik, and is now owned by Eastman Chemical. We prefer V-Kool for its clarity and very high infrared reduction, 93% to 98% of the entire infrared spectrum, thanks to its unique multi-layer, multi-metal construction. The NFRC gives V-Kool 70, 55 and 40 the highest performance ratings for films of their kind, and for their darkness overall.
One caution: films like this can corrode near the coast or in high humidity unless installed properly, with the water fully squeegeed out and the bottom and sides sealed with an inexpensive caulk. Where edge sealing isn’t wanted, a non-metal ceramic film may be the better choice.
Many manufacturers now make lower-cost spectrally selective films, metalized or nano particle. When V-Kool isn’t in the budget, we often use SunTek Ultra Vision. Measured in degrees of heat reduction, it outperforms 3M Prestige; its 40% shade is safe on dual-pane glass, which Prestige 40 and 50 are not; and it has a neutral, low-reflective look. It doesn’t match V-Kool, and it isn’t low-emissivity, but no one’s spectrally selective film lowers emissivity like V-Kool.
Madico, arguably the oldest film maker, offers Sunscape Select in nano particle (Pure Vision) and ceramic (Madico Advanced Ceramic) versions. Both carry the best standard glass warranty: 5 years on thermal breakage and 5 years on dual-pane seals, compared with 5 and 3, or 2 and 2, for most of the industry. Madico and V-Kool are arguably the clearest films on the market to look through.
Exterior films
Most manufacturers offer exterior films in at least silver, often bronze. Hanita has the best overall range and warranties, with exterior versions of every category and warranties from 3 to 15 years. I rarely need to recommend exterior film, but for hard-to-reach windows or certain glass types it can be the best choice, with outstanding performance. To get the full warranty, it usually has to be sealed on all four sides with a structural sealant such as Dow 795 or 995.
Safety and security films
Safety and security film saves lives by holding glass together on impact or in an explosion, and is used worldwide for blast mitigation and theft deterrence. We like LLumar Magnum, Bekaert Armorgard and Madico 8 mil films, because they pass the large and small missile tests with better large-missile and blast ratings than most, and they are much clearer to look through. 3M’s Ultra films, in our experience, are hazy, distorted and fail quickly. My own garage window has 3M Ultra safety film that failed after three years. (Yes, I know I need to redo it.)
Auto, truck and RV films
Car films fall into similar categories, from lowest to highest price:
- Non-reflective dyed: the least expensive and lowest performing, removing 30% to 40% of the heat. Still much better than nothing.
- High-performance or hybrid metalized: metal added to the dye for more heat reduction per shade, 40% to 66%, but the higher the heat reduction, the more reflective the look.
- Full metal: great heat reduction for the darkness, but the most reflective, and prone to blurring on back windows that must be heat-shrunk. Rarely chosen, and we no longer offer it.
- Ceramic and carbon: popular now because they reject heat like metalized film without the reflective look. Carbon gives a color that won’t fade; ceramic alone can look grayish or reflective, so carbon is often added for a neutral tone. Carbon-only films reduce heat about as much as dyed film, so they aren’t worth the extra cost. All are non-conductive, so they won’t interfere with radio, cell or Bluetooth signals.
- Nano particle: the newest and usually most expensive. Low or no reflectivity, heat reduction as good as metal or carbon ceramic, and designed to remove the most infrared, which makes them spectrally selective. Also non-conductive.
V-Kool 70, Huper Optik ceramic and Madico Advanced Ceramic also make great car films if you want strong heat reduction without a dark look; we apply V-Kool 70 or similar films to windshields every month.
For vehicles, we offer a mix of films because that gives the best overall program, all with lifetime warranties covering bubbling, peeling, fading and color change for as long as the original buyer owns the vehicle: Sungard Black Pearl Non Reflective, Black Pearl High Performance, Madico Onyx High Performance, Geoshield Pro Nano and Winco. Winco is the clearest, most natural car film I have ever seen.
We have used many other auto film brands over the years, including LLumar, SolarGard, American Standard, Global, 3M and Johnson. They all offer lifetime warranties and honor them, but a warranty claim is still a big inconvenience for the customer and the dealer. With our current lineup we have had minimal issues for years, compared with weekly returns when we sold 3M.
Decorative films
Most manufacturers sell decorative films, but many don’t make them; they rebox products made in Korea, Japan and China. 3M’s graphics division offers a large range, including Di-Noc, an amazing product with textures like wood and stone. 3M, Oracal and Avery make the best vinyls. For basic frost films, any major manufacturer will do, usually with a 5-year warranty on interior glass and 0 to 5 years on exterior glass.
Manufacturers worth watching
SunTek, now part of Eastman Chemical alongside Southwall (V-Kool and Huper Optik), LLumar and Vista, has been one of the fastest-growing film makers, and its newer dual reflectives look very good for less money. Madico bought the Sungard brand and equipment and has invested in capacity and research. Smaller makers like Hanita, Global, Johnson and Geoshield keep improving too, and that competition pushes everyone forward. A new innovation can come from any manufacturer at any time.
What it really comes down to
- The dealer has to do their homework, choose responsibly, and refuse to be leveraged by manufacturers.
- You need to do your homework on the dealer. Are they certified by the International Window Film Association? Properly licensed and insured? Do they train their sales and installation teams well?
- Can they back up their claims with data, certifications and references?
- Do they follow IWFA installation standards and offer a written labor guarantee?
- Do the manufacturers they buy from offer good, sustainable warranties?
I hope this helps you choose both a film and a dealer. Contact us any time for free, honest advice.
Call today! Local: 480-985-9293 · Out of Valley: 1-888-577-TINT (8468)
Made In The Shade Inc. Where YOU Are The COOLEST!