Window film and exterior sun screens both cut heat and glare, but they work very differently. Here is how they compare, point by point.
| Window film | Sun screens | |
|---|---|---|
| UV protection | Stops over 99% of UV | Varies widely, never close to 99% |
| Performance through the day | Full efficiency all day; there are no holes | Varies a lot with the sun’s angle, because of the mesh |
| Performance over time | Reflects energy with metals or ceramics that don’t wear out, so performance holds | Mainly absorbs energy; as the mesh fades and loosens, more energy gets through (often 10% less effective in the first year) |
| Heat reduction | Reduces radiant, convective and conductive heat by 10% to 75% | 10% to 70%, but heats the area around the screen and the outside of the glass |
| View | Much clearer | You look through mesh |
| Appearance | Pleasing from inside and out | Can give a house a boarded-up look |
| Warranty | Lifetime on residential film | 2 to 5 years, on the screen only |
| Thermal glass breakage | Rare when guidelines are followed, and covered by manufacturers’ warranties, along with seal failure | Can happen, with no coverage |
| Cleaning | Soap, water and a soft cloth or squeegee; both sides of the glass are easy to clean | Never quite look clean, deteriorate faster if scrubbed, and must come off to clean the outside glass |
| Installers and standards | IWFA-certified installers, with manufacturer-authorized standards guaranteed in writing | No industry association, poor warranties |
| Security | Holds broken glass together, deters break-ins, and is available as safety and blast film | Easily removed, including by thieves |
| Installation | Goes on almost any glass with no alterations (some glass types have limits); removed and replaced from inside | Mounting hardware may need to attach to the building or frame |
| Ventilation | No protection when the window is open | Poor ventilation; a separate bug screen is needed to let in air |
| HOA rules | Some HOAs limit reflectivity | Almost all HOAs allow them, though some restrict the color |
| Cost | May cost a little more up front, but far less over time | Cheaper initially, but usually need replacing within 5 years |
When sun screens make sense
The facts weigh heavily in film’s favor, but there are situations where a sun screen is the better, or only, choice:
- a covered patio where you want something retractable
- an extreme window where film and a covering together still can’t control the heat or light
- when you want the sun’s warmth at some times of year, and can remove the screens or swap shades seasonally
- when you expect to move within 3 to 5 years and want to spend less up front
The right solution for every window
We don’t push one product, because we install all of them:
- Window film: sun control, safety and security, and graphic and decorative
- Window coverings from Hunter Douglas, Skandia and others: mini blinds, wood and faux wood blinds, verticals, roller and panel shades, Roman shades, cellular shades, and wood, vinyl and hybrid shutters
- Interior and exterior sun screens and roller shades in many colors and openness levels, from makers such as SunTex and Phifer
We’ll help you find the right balance of control, beauty and budget for every window in your home or office.
Call today! Local: 480-985-9293 · Out of Valley: 1-888-577-TINT (8468)
Made In The Shade Inc. Where YOU Are The COOLEST!