
It’s time to revisit the “on-angle” Total Solar Energy Rejection measurement. 3M uses it to market its Prestige window film line, and if you are shopping for film, this is a case of buyer beware.
What 3M is claiming
The window film industry has always measured Total Solar Energy Rejection (TSER) with sunlight hitting the glass at 90°, straight on. 3M reasons that the sun is rarely at that angle, especially in the hottest part of the day, so it needed a film that performs better “on-angle”, and a measurement to prove it. That measurement then found its way into the marketing.
A note from experience: when Prestige first came out, its heat reduction percentages were printed on the sample cards and technical sheets, just like every other film. Within a few months, new cards appeared, for Prestige only, without the heat reduction numbers and with a new term: “TSER on angle”. Why? The heat reduction was no better than 3M’s own neutral metalized films, so customers saw no reason to upgrade. I still have the original cards.
The industry has never promoted angular measurements, and the NFRC does not include angular data on its product certification labels. Yet the public is left to assume this is a standard measurement that sets one product apart.
Fact vs. fiction
Some dealers make it worse. One responded on its website to the point that 3M’s on-angle spec is not supported by the NFRC by saying the spec is “new technology”, that no other manufacturer can rate its products this way, and that Prestige’s 200-layer nano construction makes it possible.
Fact: the NFRC does not support the on-angle TSER specification. All manufacturers measure total solar energy rejection at 90° to the glass.
Fiction: that this is new technology, that no other manufacturer can rate its film this way, or that 3M’s multi-layer construction makes the measurement possible.
Any manufacturer could report on-angle ratings if it wanted to. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory has offered software for many years that calculates angular performance for window coatings and films on almost any glass, and the Department of Energy recognizes it. 3M did not invent this measurement, and neither did any other film maker.
Running the numbers ourselves
Using the LBNL software, we compared three 70% visible light films on clear single-pane glass, 0.120″ thick. The figures are Solar Heat Gain Coefficient (SHGC), where lower is better.
| Film | 0° | 30° | 60° | 80° | 90° |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3M Prestige 70 | 0.503 | 0.499 | 0.427 | 0.188 | 0.00 |
| Vista VS 70 | 0.476 | 0.471 | 0.404 | 0.178 | 0.00 |
| V-Kool 70 | 0.440 | 0.435 | 0.373 | 0.164 | 0.00 |
Two things stand out. First, on-angle data exists for all three brands, not just Prestige. Second, Prestige 70 is outperformed by both other films at every angle.
More important is the pattern. As the sun’s angle increases, every film performs better, until at 90° above the window they all reject all of the sun’s energy. So does plain clear glass, for the simple reason that less energy passes through glass the steeper the sun is. The idea that one company’s technology makes on-angle performance possible, or unbeatable, does not hold up.
Beware the BTU meter demo
Be wary of the on-angle “BTU meter” test some 3M dealers demonstrate. Prestige is optimized to block the part of the infrared range that those meters measure, which is not the whole infrared range.
I know this firsthand. I was a 3M dealer for 14 years, for several of them the largest in Arizona and one of the largest in the country, and a 3M Advanced Certified Trainer for over 10 years. I was part of this until I obtained and studied 3M’s own lab data, reports and presentations showing how the film “fooled the BTU meters”. I still have them.
What we recommend instead
Measured honestly, V-Kool outperforms the others. That is why V-Kool is our premier spectrally selective film, followed by Geoshield and Madico Advanced Ceramic.
Manufacturers should keep moving toward standardized measurements verified by respected third parties like the NFRC. And dealers owe it to their customers to learn the facts, so they stop passing on inaccurate claims that discredit a product as valuable as window film. Customers deserve accurate, relevant data, and to be treated with integrity.
Call today! Local: 480-985-9293 · Out of Valley: 1-888-577-TINT (8468)
Made In The Shade Inc. Where YOU Are The COOLEST!